Former UK minister Alan Milburn has proposed that large employers give meaningful feedback to all unsuccessful job applicants under 25. His recommendation addresses so-called job ghosting, when an employer fails to respond after an application or interview. The proposal forms part of a major review into young people who are not in employment, education or training-those dubbed as Neets. For jobseekers across the UK, the silence from employers has become a significant barrier that undermines confidence and makes it harder to improve their next application. The review aims to reduce the proportion of Neets from 13% to about 5% by 2036. The report’s proposals relate mostly to England, with a recommendation that Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland adapt the principles to suit their own systems. Milburn’s report describes this “wall of silence” as especially hard on young people because it leaves them with “nothing to learn from”. It also recognizes the time and emotional investment involved in submitting applications. Jobseekers Describe Repeated Employer Silence Yugraj Samrai, a 23-year-old from Coventry, has submitted hundreds of job applications since graduating with a marketing degree in July. He hears nothing back 30 to 40% of the time, an experience that makes him feel like a statistic rather than a person. He spent considerable time and energy submitting each application but received nothing in return, not even a basic acknowledgment of whether he would progress to the next stage. “I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I’ll progress onto the next stage or not,” said Samrai. “I’ve spent all that time and energy submitting my application but got nothing in return.” Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, submitted 70 applications before getting an interview in September after being unemployed since June. She describes her biggest challenge throughout the job-hunting process as not getting feedback about why she didn’t secure the position, which prevents her from knowing what to fix next time. She has also been ghosted after interviews several times, with most roles yielding no rejection at all-just complete silence that leaves her frustrated and unable to learn from the experience. Research Reveals Widespread Problem Across UK Research by head-hunting firm Robert Walters found that 86% of UK job hunters surveyed said a hiring organization had ignored their applications with no response at all. The data confirms that job ghosting has become a widespread problem across the British labor market, affecting jobseekers at all levels and leaving them demoralized while denting their confidence. The silence is particularly damaging for younger applicants who lack the professional network or experience to interpret what went wrong during the selection process. Employers face large volumes of applications in an increasingly competitive market, making it difficult to respond to everyone individually. Artificial intelligence tools now enable applicants to submit more applications with less effort, adding further pressure to already overwhelmed hiring teams. Many companies treat post-interview communication as an administrative chore at the end of a long recruitment process, sending generic template emails or nothing at all. Yet candidates view that same communication as a lifeline that could help them improve their skills and calibrate their job search strategy. Why Interview Feedback Benefits Employers Too Giving interview feedback may appear to be extra work with little immediate payoff once a candidate is rejected, but it carries strategic value for employers beyond simple courtesy. Rejected candidates talk to friends, post on professional forums, and remember how companies treated them when things didn’t go their way. A talented engineer who doesn’t secure a senior role today might become a VP at another firm in four years, or might warn peers away from applying to that same organization. Hiring reputation extends far beyond the people who sign offer letters. There is also a practical benefit that many recruiters overlook when they skip feedback. Good feedback helps candidates calibrate their job search, which means fewer mismatched applications and less noise for everyone later on. If someone repeatedly fails technical screens because their system design explanations are too abstract, telling them saves months of frustration and reduces the volume of poorly targeted applications flooding into hiring pipelines. Better-informed candidates make better applications, which ultimately makes the entire recruitment ecosystem more efficient. What Candidates Actually Want After Rejection Most jobseekers don’t demand a three-page psychological profile when they request interview feedback-they want something much simpler and far more useful. First, they want specificity rather than vague platitudes. Saying “you lacked leadership experience” leaves a candidate guessing about what went wrong, whereas explaining “in the second round, we looked for examples where you pushed back on a product decision and owned the outcome” gives actionable insight they can apply to the next interview. Second, candidates want honesty about whether the rejection stemmed from skills, experience, cultural fit, or simply a stronger competing applicant. Third, jobseekers value constructive suggestions on how to improve their candidacy for similar roles in the future. Simple recommendations such as gaining experience in a particular tool, seeking leadership opportunities, or clarifying technical explanations can guide professional development far more effectively than silence. Fourth, they appreciate timely responses-hearing nothing for weeks or months after an interview compounds the frustration and leaves candidates in limbo, unable to move forward confidently with other opportunities. Practical Steps to Improve Application Success Career coaches recommend that jobseekers tailor their resume to each specific role rather than sending out large numbers of identical applications. Customizing a CV to highlight the most relevant skills and experiences for a particular position increases the likelihood of progressing to the interview stage. Candidates should also ask directly for feedback after interviews, even if the employer doesn’t volunteer it, as many hiring managers will provide at least brief notes when prompted. Building a professional network through industry events and online platforms can also yield referrals that bypass the black hole of anonymous online applications. The Milburn review represents a significant shift in expectations around employer obligations to unsuccessful applicants. If implemented across large UK firms, the feedback requirement could transform the job-hunting experience for thousands of young people currently stuck in the cycle of silent rejections. Whether employers embrace the recommendation or resist it as an administrative burden will determine whether job ghosting remains a defining feature of the British labor market or becomes a relic of a less transparent era. For now, candidates like Samrai and Johns continue to submit applications with the hope that someone, somewhere will finally tell them why their efforts keep falling short. Post navigation Trump Signs Law Ending Penny Production After Nearly 250 Years American Airlines Retires International First Class as U.S. Carriers Embrace Mass Luxury